three date rule Archives - The Crush Confidential

Why Shared Values Outweigh Shared Hobbies in Relationships

Shared values in dating: lifestyle alignment as the foundation of love.

When it comes to dating, it’s easy to be swept away by common interests. Maybe you both love hiking, bingeing the same Netflix series, or trying out new restaurants. While those shared hobbies can spark fun and connection early on, they don’t necessarily guarantee long-term compatibility.

At The Crush Confidential, we see time and time again that the couples who thrive aren’t just bonded by what they do together—they’re united by what they believe in.


Why Values Matter More Than Activities

Hobbies can change. Interests fade. Life circumstances evolve. But values—like integrity, ambition, family priorities, spirituality, or financial mindset—are much more enduring.

A couple who both love hiking may get along on Saturday mornings, but if one values building a family and the other values total independence, tension is inevitable down the road. True compatibility comes from aligning on what matters most at the core.

(Related reading: The Three-Date Rule: Why You Shouldn’t Judge Compatibility Too Quickly).


The Role of Lifestyle Alignment

Amanda Hood, founder of The Crush Confidential, often emphasizes lifestyle alignment as the foundation of a successful relationship. It’s not just about liking the same things—it’s about wanting the same kind of life.

For example:

  • Do you both envision kids in your future?

  • How do you approach finances and career goals?

  • Is faith or spirituality important in your daily life?

  • How do you balance work, family, and personal time?

When these answers are aligned, the relationship feels natural. Shared hobbies become a bonus instead of the glue holding things together.


How to Shift Your Dating Mindset

If you’re single and looking for a partner, here are a few ways to focus on values over activities:

  1. Ask intentional questions early. Instead of “What do you like to do for fun?” try “What’s most important to you right now in life?”

  2. Pay attention to patterns. Notice not just what someone says, but how they live. Do their actions reflect values that match your own?

  3. Don’t overlook differences. It’s okay to have separate hobbies—as long as your deeper goals align.

For more guidance, Amanda recently shared in her Now in the Nati interview that 95% of her clients are single parents—and for them, lifestyle alignment is even more crucial than ever.


The Bottom Line

Shared hobbies might get you a second date. Shared values are what build a lifetime partnership.

Want more insights? Explore our post on Intentional Dating: The Secret to Finding Love Faster or learn why dating with kids requires a mindset shift toward clarity and purpose.

The Three-Date Rule: Why You Shouldn’t Judge Compatibility Too Quickly

three date rule in modern dating

When it comes to dating, first impressions carry a lot of weight. But at The Crush Confidential, we believe that real compatibility takes time to reveal itself. That’s why we encourage all of our clients to embrace what we call the Three-Date Rule.

Too often, people dismiss a potential partner after just one meeting — maybe the conversation wasn’t effortless, maybe nerves got in the way, or maybe the “spark” wasn’t instant. But here’s the truth: genuine chemistry often needs space to grow.


Why Three Dates Matter

  1. First-Date Nerves Are Real
    Many singles put too much pressure on the first date. You’re both trying to impress, gauge compatibility, and decide if there’s a future — all in a single evening. No wonder it feels overwhelming! By the second or third date, those walls start to come down and authenticity has a chance to shine.

    (Curious why first impressions aren’t always accurate? Check out Psychology Today’s research on first impressions.)

  2. Chemistry Can Be Subtle
    Attraction doesn’t always strike like lightning. Sometimes, it builds slowly as you discover shared values, humor, and lifestyle alignment. A person who feels “just okay” on date one might feel like an amazing match by date three.

    (Related: our blog on How to Spot Your Relationship Green Flags dives deeper into this idea.)

  3. Lifestyle Alignment Takes Time
    One of the most important parts of a lasting relationship is whether your day-to-day lives and long-term goals truly fit together. These aren’t always obvious in the first conversation, but a few dates in, you’ll start to notice how naturally your rhythms align.

    (See also: The Gottman Institute’s research on long-term compatibility.)


How to Approach the Three-Date Rule

  • Go in with curiosity, not judgment. Instead of looking for red flags on date one, try noticing small green flags that could grow into something meaningful.

  • Be open to surprises. The person who doesn’t immediately sweep you off your feet might actually be the partner who fits your lifestyle and future best.

  • Give yourself permission to slow down. Love isn’t a race, and taking three dates to decide is a way of investing in your future clarity.

For more on this approach, read our blog: Intentional Dating: Why Slowing Down Leads to Stronger Connections.


The Bottom Line

The Three-Date Rule is not about forcing chemistry that isn’t there — it’s about giving compatibility the chance to show up. At The Crush Confidential, we’ve seen countless success stories come from clients who were patient enough to let sparks turn into something lasting.

So before you say “no” after one date, consider saying “yes” to two more. You might be surprised at the connection waiting to unfold.